Confronting the New Property Tax Revolt: The TL:DR on
Real Estate’s Big Challenge
Tax Foundation's Jared Walczak recently published 'Confronting the New Property Tax Revolt,' analyzing reform options for today's property tax challenges. We’ve read the article and summarized the positions. For the complete 39-minute read, see the original article.
The Current Property Tax Crisis:
Property values have skyrocketed 27% above inflation since 2020, with some markets seeing even more dramatic increases. In fast-growing areas like Bozeman, Montana, and Boise, Idaho, home values have doubled in just seven years. This surge means homeowners face significantly higher tax bills even when local governments haven't officially raised rates. The result? A nationwide push for property tax reform, with some states even considering complete elimination of the tax.
Popular Solutions That Actually Backfire According to Tax Foundation:
The Most Promising Solution per Tax Foundation: Levy Limits
Levy limits target the real problem: uncontrolled growth in total property tax collections. Here's how they work:
Why This Matters:
Property taxes critically fund essential local services like schools, emergency services, and infrastructure.
Property values have skyrocketed 27% above inflation since 2020, with some markets seeing even more dramatic increases. In fast-growing areas like Bozeman, Montana, and Boise, Idaho, home values have doubled in just seven years. This surge means homeowners face significantly higher tax bills even when local governments haven't officially raised rates. The result? A nationwide push for property tax reform, with some states even considering complete elimination of the tax.
Popular Solutions That Actually Backfire According to Tax Foundation:
- Complete Elimination: While politically appealing, eliminating property taxes would force a shift to income or sales taxes, which research shows could reduce economic growth by nearly 3%
- Assessment Caps: These limits look good on paper but create a "two-tier" tax system where new homeowners pay dramatically more than longtime residents for identical properties
- State Tax Rebates: When states step in with rebates, local governments often respond by maintaining higher rates, leading to higher overall taxation
- Rate Limits: Simply capping tax rates doesn't help when the problem is rising property values, not rate increases
The Most Promising Solution per Tax Foundation: Levy Limits
Levy limits target the real problem: uncontrolled growth in total property tax collections. Here's how they work:
- Automatically caps how much additional revenue can be collected from existing properties
- Forces tax rates downward when property values rise sharply
- Allows revenue from genuine new growth (like new construction)
- Treats all property owners equally, regardless of how long they've owned their home
- Includes options for voter-approved increases when communities want to fund specific projects
Why This Matters:
Property taxes critically fund essential local services like schools, emergency services, and infrastructure.
Bottom Line:
According to the Tax Foundation, the property tax system isn't broken - it just needs better guardrails. While many proposed solutions sound great in theory, levy limits emerge as the most practical way to protect homeowners while preserving local government's most important revenue tool.
Note: This summary is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or tax advice. For guidance specific to your situation, please contact us.
REDD Accounting is a global firm specializing in property accounting and bookkeeping services for real estate companies. Whether you are a small-scale operation or managing a large portfolio of properties, we have the expertise and resources to support your unique needs in navigating these complex tax challenges.
Need help developing your property tax strategy?
Dive Deeper
/ Redd
© Redd Accounting 2024